Parental Alienation Syndrome Diagnosis and TreatmentTables 1-3

Table 1:

DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS OF THE THREE LEVELS OF PARENTALALIENATION SYNDROME (PAS) CHILDREN

Note: The diagnosis of PAS is based uponthe level of symptoms in the child, not on the symptom level ofthe alienator

CHILDSSYMPTOM LEVEL

MILD

MODERATE

SEVERE

PRIMARY SYMPTOMATIC MANIFESTATIONS

The Campaign of Denigration

Minimal

Moderate

Formidable

Weak, Frivolous, orAbsurd Rationalizations for the Deprecation

Minimal

Moderate

Multiple absurd rationalizations

Lack of Ambivalence

Normal Ambivalence

No ambivalence

No ambivalence

The Independent-ThinkerPhenomenon

Usually absent

Present

Present

Reflexive Supportof the Alienating Parent in the Parental Conflict

Minimal

Present

Present

Absence of Guilt

Normal guilt

Minimal to no guilt

No guilt

Borrowed Scenarios

Minimal

Present

Present

Spread of the Animosity
to the Extended Family
and Friends of the
Alienated Parent

Minimal

Present

Formidable,
often fanatic

ADDITIONAL DIFFERENTIAL
DIAGNOSTIC CONSIDERATIONS

Transitional
Difficulties
at the Time of
Visitation

Usually Absent

Moderate

Formidable, or
visit not possible

Behavior During
Visitation

Good

Intermittently antagonisticand provocative

No visit, or destructiveand continually provocative behavior throughout visit

Bonding with
the Alienator

Strong, healthy

Strong, mildly tomoderately pathological

Severely pathological,often paranoid bonding

Bonding with the
Alienated Parent Prior to the Alienation

Strong, healthy,or minimally pathological

Strong, healthy,or minimally pathological

Strong, healthy,or minimally pathological

Table 1


Table 2:

DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS OF THE THREE LEVELS OF PARENTALALIENATION SYNDROME (PAS) ALIENATORS

NOTE: Whereas the diagnosisof PAS is based upon the level of symptoms in the child, the court'sdecision for custodial transfer should be based primarily on thealienator's symptom level and only secondarily on the child's levelof PAS symptoms

ALIENATORSSYMPTOM LEVEL

MILD

MODERATE

SEVERE

Bilbao luxury hotelsFrequency of ProgrammingThoughts

Occasional

Frequent

Obsessive

Frequency of Programming

Occasional

Frequent

Persistent

Frequency of ExclusionaryManeuvers

Occasional

Frequent

Whenever
possible

Violation of
Court Orders

Occasional

Occasional
to frequent

Repeatedly

Success in Manipulatingthe Legal System to Enhance the Programming*

Minimal attempts

Occasional to
moderate success

Repeatedly successful

Risk of Intensificationof Programming
After Gaining
Primary Custody

Very low

Mild
to moderate

Extremely high, tothe
point of being
almost inevitable

Table 2

*The alienator can rely on court delays and court reluctance and even refusalto penalize the alienator
with such measures as posting a bond, fines, community service, probation,house arrest, incarceration,
and custodial change.

Table 3:

DIFFERENTIALTREATMENT OF THE THREE LEVELS OF PARENTAL ALIENATION SYNDROME (PAS)CHILDREN

NOTE: Whereas thediagnosis of PAS is based upon the level of symptoms in the child,the court's decision for custodial transfer should be based primarilyon the alienator's symptom level and only secondarily on the child'slevel of PAS symptoms

CHILDS SYMPTOM LEVEL

MILD

MODERATE

SEVERE

Legal
Approaches

For Alienators in the Mild Category

Court ruling that primary custody shall remain with the alienating parent

Plan A

For Alienators in the Moderate Category

(Most Common)

  1. Court ruling that primary custody shall remain with the alienating parent
  2. Court appointment of PAS therapist
    (see note 1 and 2, below)
  3. Sanctions:

a.Post a Bond
b. Fines
c. Community Service
d. Probation
e. House arrest
f. Incarceration

Plan B

For Alienators in the Severe Category

(Occasionally necessary)

  1. Court ruling that primary custody shall be transferred to the alienated parent
  2. Court appointment of PAS therapist
    (see note 1 and 2, below)
  3. Extremely restricted visitation by the alienating parent,monitored to prevent indoctrinations

For Alienators in the Severe Category

  1. Court ruling that primary custody shall be transferred to the alienated parent
  2. Court-ordered transitional-site program

PsychotherapeuticApproaches

None usuallynecessary

Plans A and B

Treatment by a court-appointed PAS therapist1,2

Transitional-site program monitored by court-appointed PAS therapist1,2

Table 3

1. Gardner, R.A. (1998) The ParentalAlienation Syndrome, Second Edition.
Cresskill, NJ: Creative Therapeutics, Inc.
2. Gardner, R.A. (2001) Therapeutic Interventions for Children with Parental Alienation Syndrome.
Cresskill, NJ: Creative Therapeutics, Inc.

- | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |